Overall I received all "Good" and "Very Good" across the categories, and the 3 judges, except one which was "Satisfactory" from one of the judges, in the category of Visual Impact, Interpretation of the Theme. Now whilst for Visual Impact I might disagree, I think it is a very eye catching quilt, but in relation to the category, Special Themes, New Beginnings, I'm not sure I had actually entered it in the most appropriate category, so i'll give them that. ;o). The same judge described it as "A dynamic piece with appealing colours" which I think is a really positive overall comment, and made me pretty happy- especially considering this wasn't supposed to be a "show" quilt, it started out as me off on a sewing tangent!
Another of the judges commented that "A bit more quilting would have added a bit more to this, especially the background", and I can see their point, but I didn't want an over quilted piece on the actual chevrons. In retrospect, some quilting on the background white would have accentuated the chevrons, so also good feedback.
And the 3rd set of comments were overall positive, "Lovely colours and quilting to complement it" why thank you, but at this point, we head off on separate paths "Might have been better on a white on white print", nope, sorry, I prefer the solids, but ok, "or batik as background". Sorry, what was that, I didn't quite hear you, did you mention the B word? Yep, you read that correctly, batik, BATIK, are you serious, haha, no chance. I'll be honest, I hate batik, I cannot think of anything less suitable for a quilt like that I wanted to feel fresh, than a murky background, never, not going to happen, ever, EVER! I laughed out loud, I admit it. :o)
Overall, I was pretty pleased with the feedback, some good, constructive, well thought out (on the whole) comments, and considering this was thrown together Improv style with no pretensions to being a show quilt, and that the actual quilting etc was thrown together at the last minute (in a total panic, and on 3 different sewing machines), not getting torn a new one about the quality of my work is a positive. I have a feeling the Festival Of Quilts judges wont go so easy on me, but hopefully my project for that one will be up another level, we'll see, maybe not!
This quilt will have it's hanging sleeve removed in the next few days, and then it is off to its other home, not far, on the "other sofa" in our lounge. Yep, this one is going to be Mr H.O.C's sofa quilt, but in typical man style, he actually prefers this side, the back
Men! ;o)
So with all of that loving in mind, I have decided to enter this one in the Bloggers Quilt Festival, there are some amazing quilts in the competition, and this is my first time emtering that too, go and take a look, I'm in the throw quilt category.
Quilt Stats:
48 x 69 inches
Machine Quilted across the chevrons by me!
Improv pieced from solids into squares, then cross cut and pieced to create a chevron effect.
Ange x
Link here
WTF! White on white or batiks? Is the judge on meds? It is a thoroughly modern quilt and most white on white fabrics are not particularly modern. And a batik background would have totally hidden the wonderful impact of the chevrons which was the whole purpose of the quilt. What a complete moron!
ReplyDeleteShall I tell you again how much I love your quilt? Because I do!
mmmmmmm batiks. Delicious murkiness!
ReplyDeleteMy computer screen got a light spraying of drink with the batik remark - brilliant!
ReplyDeleteBatik - bleurgh!
ReplyDeleteI love this quilt, it is has such presence for such soothing colours. I would not recommend a single change, your judges are tuned into another aesthetic.
ReplyDeleteI think it is lovely and you are brave to enter it into a tradional quilt show. Batik background! I laughed too! NO WAY Di x
ReplyDeleteWow, that took ages to get home! Great job on the feedback, well, err, except that batik - WTF?! I never got any feedback
ReplyDeleteIt's great that you got such positive feedback overall. The white on white/ batik comment illustrates the wide gulf between ( as Leanne very diplomatically puts it) different aesthetics. I know which side of the fence I'm on ( and it doesn't include batiks or white on white)
ReplyDeleteyou know it's fab and they don't know anything...batiks shatiks. Now I'm intrigued about your FoQ entry :)
ReplyDeleteSurprised they didn't suggest a bit of sparkle and some maybe a bit of Civil War beige to top it off!
ReplyDeleteVomit - batiks...love your quilt just as it is and the white sets the colours off perfectly.
ReplyDeleteLol! Apparently the show you sent it to isn't used to the modern quilting aesthetic. :-) Overall, pretty decent feedback - I know how tough quilting judges can be...
ReplyDeleteGreat quilt, high-impact. "Appealing." :-)
It's a fab quilt - despite it's lack of batik ;) - and I"m in awe of you entering it! I went to my first proper Patchwork & Quilting show on Friday and am starting to debate whether to enter a quilt next year. It feels a bit scary so we'll see.
ReplyDeleteEuw - batiks *shudder*...what Susan said!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteOh wow, I'm so happy to hear how many others hate batik too! I thought it was just me haha. I think your quilt's a winner. Great work, I wouldn't change a thing :)
ReplyDeleteI had a giggle at the Batik comment too. It's a wonderful quilt front and back.
ReplyDeleteI love the back of this quilt almost as much as I love the front! Going back up to look at the front again and figure out how you managed to so beautifully outline the chevrons in the improv pieced section. You were so brave to enter it in the festival, so glad it went so well for you :)
ReplyDeleteThese are such gorgeous, soothing colors. It's a great entry. And kudos to you for having the nerve to enter into a judged competition - not sure I'm that brave yet!
ReplyDelete*guffaws* Your batik indignation comes through loud and clear!! But on the whole you got amazing comments , bearing in mind this was the equivalent of a Tchaikovsky afficionado judging a Daft Punk CD! I love it completely and totally.
ReplyDeleteYay! I still can't believe you managed to finish this amid moving hell!! Brilliant, well done, fantastic comments from the judges........now are you sure you don't want to try Batik next time?? ;-\ urhhhh
ReplyDeleteWhite on white is yucky and I hate batiks as much as I hate Aida for hand stitching and if you've ever read my stitching blog you will know I hate that a lot!!! But your quilt is very yummy.
ReplyDeleteyours is such a pretty quilt :-) I can't believe how many people hate batiks though. Its all I can buy where I live in Indonesia - and there is such a variety in style, design and colour - its not all bad!
ReplyDelete